Showing posts with label Rattlesnake Middle School. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rattlesnake Middle School. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 20, 2014

Linking the School Facility Study recommendations with Voting Record of Former MCPS Trustee Rosemary Harrison (who is NOW serving on this Committee!!)

Missoula County Public Schools, in my opinion, is making some drastic mistakes in its facilities planning.
And no wonder. The people involved in the planning process are none other than the people who got us into this mess in the first place.
One person, and I believe one of the major culprits in this latest facility plan fiasco, is Rosemary Harrison. Harrison voted to close several schools: Dickinson, Roosevelt, Prescott, Mt. Jumbo, and Rattlesnake Middle School.  Harrison went on to vote to sell Roosevelt School in 2005. Harrison also went on to vote for the lease of Prescott School to the competing private school Missoula International School in 2004 only weeks after the closure.
Other culprits in this gigantically expensive decades-long facility merry-go-round are:
 Roosevelt Closure - (circa 1998) - Superintendent Vagner, MCPS administrators, in addition to Harrison are Trustees Hemphill (Cummings), and others for which I am unsure at this time.
Roosevelt School Sale - (2005) – In addition to Harrison other Trustees voting for this sale were Jenda Hemphill, Toni Rehbein, Scott Bixler, and Joe Toth.
First North East School Closure Vote - (2004) - Superintendent Clark, MCPS administrators, and in addition to Harrison were Trustees Jenda Hemphill, Naomi Kimbell, and David Merrill.
Second North East School Closure Vote - (2004) – (This second vote was due to a repeat of the first school closure decision process due to violations in open meeting laws) - Superintendent Jim Clark, MCPS administrators, and in addition to Harrison were Trustees Jenda Hemphill, Toni Rehbein (formerly Toni Smartt), Scott Bixler, and Joe Toth.
Lease of Prescott School to Missoula International School – 2004 – Superintendent Clark, MCPS administrators, and in addition to Harrison were Trustees Jenda Hemphill, Naomi Kimbell, Scott Bixler, and Joe Toth.
Two lease extension of Prescott School to Missoula International School were approved by disloyal and malfeasance Trustees: one in 2009 and the other in 2011 under the leadership of Superintendent Alex Apostle (was this why he was hired?)
Did Missoulians know that in this facility planning study has NOT given the closed schools the value of an open school – that is all closed schools were considered INACTIVE and all open schools are considered ACTIVE!!
Look at the connection that is being made in this post and you will see how us Missoulians are being taken for a ride – a very expensive ride. Many of the schools which were closed, sold, and/or leased to the competition by Rosemary Harrison are the schools which are now considered INACTIVE and most likely the reason why Harrison was selected to be in this planning study. HARRISON (AND OTHER DISLOYAL PEOPLE) WANT TO COMPLETE WHAT SHE STARTED – the non-use or disposal of the schools for which she closed: Dickinson, Roosevelt (check - she accomplished the disposal of this property), Prescott, Mt. Jumbo, and Rattlesnake Middle School (check -she accomplished the disappearance of this school).
If Rosemary Harrison, other MCPS Facility Study people, and the MCPS officials  complete the plan that is outlined in this article, we Missoulians (students, families, taxpayers, neighborhoods) ARE THE LOSERS – BIG TIME!!
 This latest study is a fraud (just like others before it) because of who is involved and the complete and utter lack of due diligence in school size, school configuration, i.e. K-8 vs. middle schools, costs of busing, costs of remodeling vs. building a new school, etc.).
Please Missoulians, stick up for Prescott School and other INACTIVE schools, such as Whittier, Dickinson, Mt. Jumbo, and Jefferson – THESE SCHOOLS NEED A VOICE! It is the NEIGHBORHOOD SMALL SCHOOL THAT IS KING IN PROVIDING A GOOD EDUCATION FOR OUR STUDENTS. Contact MCPS school officials at: Missoula County Public Schools, 214 S. Sixth West, Missoula, MT 59801.


I think that all of the above is correct – my apologies if not.

Tuesday, March 25, 2014

Today is the 10th anniverary of one of the most tragic school decisions in Missoula's history, the closure of Rattlesnake Middle School, Prescott School, and Mount Jumbo School

On March 25, at 1:00 a.m., 2004, the Missoula County Public Schools Board of Trustees voted to close THREE schools on the north side of Missoula. This was, as the title of the post states, one of the most tragic decisions ever in Missoula's educational scene. The neighborhood school is the lynch pin of a successful educational system and to take is away is heartbreaking for all.

The votes for the closures were: Rosemary Harrison, Chair of the Board, Jenda Hemphill, Naomi Kimbell(who just weeks later would become the executive director of Missoula International School), and David Merrill (who was elected to reopen Prescott School in a prior year therefore dismissing his mandate for supporting Prescott School).

In the second vote for the closures(this was due to an Open Meeting lawsuit filed by Molly Moody and Allan Oines) the closure MCPS Trustees were Rosemary Harrison, Jenda Hemphill, Toni Rehbein (past President and Vice President of Missoula International School), Scott Bixler, and Joe Toth.

The superintendent of Missoula County Public Schools at the time of the school closures was Jim Clark. Clark in psm's opinion will go down as one of the country's worst superintendents due to his shortsighted, mismanaged, and cold-hearted decisions. During Clark's tenure another tragic decision was approved by MCPS, the sale of Roosevelt School to St. Josephs School, a Catholic school.

The negative consequences have been many. Instead of saving money the school closures have cost Missoulians most likely millions of  dollars. East Missoula children attend Bonner in droves. Many Rattlesnake area children and other Missoula children now attend Missoula International School which is now located in Prescott School in a most disloyal decision shortly after the closures costing taxpayers now in the millions due to funding formulas based on enrollment. Thousands and thousands of dollars have gone into renovating the schools to which the children were relocated. Busing costs have increased. We, the public and perhaps even school officials will never know the true cost of the these school closures. The school district will try to keep the ongoing costs from public view as much as possible. For example, psm found that the removing of the science equipment taken out of Rattlesnake Middle School cost the district approximately $10,000! This information was revealed due to a Request for Documents case.

Also tragic were the ties and the bonds that broke when our children were torn away from the schools for which they knew for so long. Strong friendships were broken. Teachers whom loved their schools and who had taught in the schools for decades were asked to teach in a totally new environment. Traditions which were recognized for decades were ended.

What a tragedy!!!

Prescott School Missoula was so effected by this decision as a son was to attend Rattlesnake Middle School the following year. Instead of walking a couple of blocks to school for his 6th-8th grades, he was forced to attend  a school quite far from home which was by the way overcrowded from the beginning, Washington Middle School. Two of three sons attended Prescott School and even psm's grandmother attended Prescott in the early 1900's!! Prescott School Missoula has never gotten over this tragic decision and is why psm had created this blog. Prescott School must be reopened so this tragic decision lasts as few years as possible.

Our hearts were broken into a million pieces 10 years ago today.

May we never forget so that it does not happen to children in Missoula again.

Sunday, November 3, 2013

Booming student population pushes need for MCPS long-range facilities plan - Missoulian article in November 2, 2013 edition written by Betsy Cohen

Click on the link below to read an article by Missoulian reporter Betsy Cohen in the November 3rd edition reporting on the overcrowding of Missoula County Public Schools such as Rattlesnake School, just up the road from Prescott School.

The school district has been disloyal and negligent in actions taken which affect our Rattlesnake Valley students.

They have closed and sold Lincoln School (1986?) so that it is not available for handling the overflow from Rattlesnake School.

MCPS Trustees then closed Prescott School (2004) and subsequently leased it (also 2004) to a private school Missoula International School.

Citizens, including a math professor at the University of Montana, have figured that the losses to the district have been in the hundreds of thousands and now after 9 years of the Prescott School/MIS lease the loses must be in the millions of dollars.

This is all due to the state funding formula which attaches approximately $5,000 to each student.

So when a student decides to attend a private school the district loses that $5,000.  It is significant when a Missoula student decides to home school or attend a private school. It is even more significant and downright disloyal on the part of MCPS trustees and administrators when the student ATTENDS A PRIVATE SCHOOL WHICH IS HOUSED IN A PUBLIC SCHOOL which is the case of Missoula International School School students at Prescott School.

Another example of disloyalty by MCPS Trustees is the sale of Roosevelt School to St. Joseph's School in 2005. The enrollment of St. Joseph's School grew almost every year since the lease was approved around 1998 (not exactly sure of the year) and especially after the sale in 2005.

Families will surely take into consideration the school facility when deciding on a school including a private school and perhaps more so if a school is private. In each of the cases mentioned the public school was a HUGE UPGRADE IN THE PRIVATE SCHOOL'S PREVIOUS FACILITY/FACILITIES!!

The above cannot be overemphasized. The reason why these private schools pursue the public facility is to improve their school so as to attract additional students (which by the way come from the pool of children which attend MCPS).

Prescott School Missoula went before the Board for most every discussion of the leasing of Prescott School and before that for every attempt at closure.  Along with others, psm mentioned the upcoming enrollment increase, that of the echo echo boom children (the grandchildren of the baby boomers).

This future increase of students throughout the district was substantiated by work done by Dr. Larry Swanson and others. Dr. Swanson had contributed many hours free of charge to the district before 2004 and in 2009 he was contracted to do a comprehensive study for the distinct. (See tab above on this blog).

All of the free and professional work by Dr. Swanson was brushed aside, at the peril of MCPS children and Missoula taxpayers, by the Trustees at this time.

The Trustees whom voted for the 2004 north side closures were: Chairwoman Rosemary Harrison, Trustees Jenda Hemphill, Naomi Kimbell, and David Merrill.

The Trustees whom voted for the 2004 north side closures in the second vote brought on by an open meeting lawsuit against the district by Molly Moody and Allan Oines, were: Rosemary Harrison, Jenda Hemphill, Naomi Kimbell (who later became MIS's executive director - see multiple posts of this blog!), Toni Rehbein, Scott Bixler, and Joe Toth. Trustee Carol Bellin was the lone dissenter.

The Trustees whom voted for the lease of Prescott School to Missoula International School are: Rosemary Harrison, Jenda Hemphill, Naomi Kimbell, Joe Toth, and Scott Bixler. Toni Rehbein recused herself from the vote (See multiple posts on the connections Toni Rehbein has with MIS), and Carol Bellin voted against the lease.

Trustees whom voted for the lease extension in 2009: Scott Bixler, Joe Toth, Joseph Knapp, and others (psm needs to look into the documents for information on other votes).

Trustees whom voted for the Prescott School/MIS lease in 2011: Scott Bixler, Shelly Wills, Joseph Knapp, and Michael Smith.

psm will correct the voting information if any is found to be incorrect and or incomplete.

All of these MCPS Trustees have shown disloyalty to the district by assisting a private school - when their loyalties are by law supposed  to be ONLY to MCPS.

The picture for this article shows a modular at Rattlesnake School.

The article states that for the first time Rattlesnake students are being sent to Paxson.

MIS has received sweat heart leases for 9 years (see blog tab titled "MIS sweartheart lease" 

MIS has been negligent in the care of the playground and perhaps other areas of the school.(See You Tube video)

 MCPS has done maintenance on Prescott School at the district's expense, going against the lease agreement which stipulates that MIS is responsible for repair and maintenance. (See You Tube video)

psm is quite sure  based on past experience that there have been other favors to MIS form the MCPS school district.

Going forward - MCPS needs to let MIS know that the lease will be terminated at the end of this school year(there is surprisingly an opt out clause in the lease - which has not been included for MCPS in past leases). 

THEN MCPS NEEDS TO REOPEN PRESCOTT SCHOOL FOR PUBLIC SCHOOL CHILDREN.

How much more proof is there that WE NEED PRESCOTT SCHOOL!!

Booming student population pushes need for MCPS long-range facilities plan

Friday, October 19, 2012

Jacobs Decision - Features a complaint by Rosemary Harrison which actually sheds light on problems with the district's and Harrison's mishandling of the 2004 school (including Prescott) closures

Below is a link to the document "Jacobs Decision" which features a complaint by former Board Chairwoman Rosemary Harrison against former Trustee Teresa Jacobs after the 2005 school board elections. 

Ironically, the state's investigation reveals that there was no wrongdoing by Teresa Jacobs and indeed shows problems with the process by which Board Chair Harrison and the MCPS school district closed three northeast Missoula schools.

After reading this document psm believes that people will see the extent of the problems with the process of closing Prescott, Mt. Jumbo, and Rattlesnake Middle Schools in 2004.

http://politicalpractices.mt.gov/content/pdf/2recentdecisions3-cfp/Jacobsdecision.pdf

Friday, September 21, 2012

Trustees tour schools, consider closure

Trustees tour schools, consider closure

Prescott School Missoula came across this article on the 2003 closure of Prescott School. 

Prescott School Missoula will comment more on the article as time permits.

Here's a quick comment though -

There is a picture of Trustees going through a school building.  They must have school closure on their minds. It appears the school is Rattlesnake Middle School as one person in the picture may be Rob Watson, the former principal at Rattlesnake Middle School (another principal that also did not speak out against the closures).

 My, how different things could have been if these Trustees would have had the highest good for students on their minds, that is the importance of a neighborhood school and the importance of small schools.

Friday, July 20, 2012

The 2004 school closures were devastating for students, teachers, and families

In 2004, at 1:00 in the morning of March 25, the Missoula County Public Schools School Board voted to close 3 schools in the northeast corner of our city. The schools were Mount Jumbo in East Missoula, Rattlesnake Middle School, and Prescott School in the Rattlesnake Valley. 

Our hearts were broken into a million pieces. There is nothing like a school closure, especially multiple school closures, to wreak havoc among a city and a school system.  There is nothing like a school closure to cause deep grief among students and their families. At these times, tears and more tears are the answer to help deal with the tragedy. Time may lessen the pain felt by a school closure, however, for many it will never completely go away.

During the school year, after their homes, students spend most of their lives in a school building. Every school has it's problems, some bigger than others, however, students are for the most part attached to their schools and show allegiance to them, and develop close knit relationships.  Additionally, school spirit can be wonderful experience for children.

The students have forged bonds with teachers and the other students. Some of these bonds are tighter than others, nevertheless they are bonds. The friendships have been cultivated over months and years.  These bonds are also nurtured as many children live in the neighborhood and attend a neighborhood school. Teachers have come to know many of their students and care for them.  Teachers may have taught some of their student's siblings and in rare cases. their mothers or fathers.  This is how is should be, close and caring relationships nurture learning and add to a good education. 

To end the relationships between students, the school building, the teachers, and the entire staff of a school requires rigorous and thoughtful study in addition to caution. This was not done in the morning of March 25, 2004 at 1:00 in the morning. 

Many Missoula County Public School students and their families as well as several teachers are still suffering the consequences of the tragic decision of four Trustees. Rosemary Harrison, Chairwoman of the Board, Jenda Hemphill, David Merrill, and Naomi Kimbell. Other Trustees who voted to close the 3 schools when there was a second closure vote due to violations of open meetings laws were: Toni Rehbein, Scott Bixler, and Joe Toth.

Monday, July 16, 2012

#6 - Naomi Kimbell: From Missoula County Public Schools Trustee to Executive Director of Missoula International School - Part 6 - Addedum


                           Part 6 - Addendum

Addendum:  Kimbell Leaves Missoula International School

1.  April 5, 2006 - Missoulian article titled, “Poverello Center names new director” - The article reports that former Naomi Kimbell was named the new executive director of Missoula’s Poverello Center.  It also states that Kimbell had been working as director of development when she took over as acting executive director and then was chosen for the permanent position. 

2.  October 7, 2006 - Missoulian article titled, “Board praises director as she leaves the post”, subtitled, “Kimbell to work on memoirs” – The article states, “The executive director of the Poverello Center will leave the job in December to go back to school.  Naomi Kimbell, who took the job on an acting basis last fall, will now turn her focus to creative writing…”   The article also states, “Kimbell is the daughter of respected novelist and short-story writer Rick DeMarinis and grew up on Wylie Avenue
with neighbors Richard Hugo and Jim Welch.” 


3.  November 26, 2006 - The Missoulian also ran an article covering the news of Naomi’s replacement for the executive director of the Poverello Center, reported by Tyler Christensen on.  The opening paragraph states, “For a relative newcomer to Missoula, Ellie Boldman Hill has already become a familiar and seemingly ubiquitous presence in the local volunteer community.”  The article continues, “Now that she’s been named executive director of the Poverello Center, she hopes to make clear her steadfast commitment to both the community and to a nonprofit that’s struggled to find a long-term leader.  Hill will replace departing director Naomi Kimbell, who resigned to pursue a writing career, starting with a master’s degree in creative writing from the University of Montana.  Kimbell led the nonprofit for a little over a year following the October 2005 departure of Joe Bischof, who ran the Poverello for three years.”



*Note:   The April 5th article reports that Kimbell spent much of her career at the YWCA.  One wonders why it skips over the fact that she served as a trustee on the MCPS school board and that she was subsequently hired as the executive director of the Missoula International School. 

*Note # 2:  The October article states that Kimbell grew up in the Rattlesnake Valley, but later chose to close two schools in the area, showing no loyalty to the neighborhood in which she grew up.



Saturday, July 14, 2012

#5 - Naomi Kimbell: From Missoula County Public Schools Trustee to Executive Director of Missoula International School

                                      Part 5  - Post 2004     

22. February 22, 2005 – A letter from Missoula International School signed by Naomi Kimbell (no date) stamped received by MCPS Superintendent’s office on February 22, 2005.  A quote from the letter states,

“It has come to our attention that Prescott may be considered an excess building to the school district.  If this is the case, Missoula International School may be interested in purchasing the building and we would like to discuss this possibility with you.  Please let us know if you would like to arrange a time to talk.   Thank you, we look forward to hearing from you.”  The letter is signed Naomi Kimbell, Executive Director, Missoula International School! 

Trustee Bellin “urged the district to review all buildings and make an analysis in a proactive manner.”

**Note:  Naomi Kimbell is now advocating for the sale of the school, for which she was responsible only months before as a MCPS trustee. If there had been a long term analysis of MCPS properties when Kimbell had served as a Trustee she would not have had to inquire about "excess properties!"

23.  March 29, 2005 - MCPS Finance and Operations Meeting - Agenda Item:  Letter from Missoula International School Regarding Prescott.  Background Information (listed under agenda item):  Discussion of a letter from Missoula International School expressing interest in purchasing Prescott.  Trustees discussed selling Prescott School to Missoula International School with Naomi representing MIS at the meeting.  No action was taken at this time.

*Note:   Not only did Naomi Kimbell gain employment by the private school which benefited from her votes on closure and leasing while serving as a trustee on the school board, she was now making a pitch for the SALE of this school.  This letter was written approximately 7 months after Kimbell resigned from the board and only 9 months after the lease was signed, indicating that the real intent of the private school was to permanently reside in Prescott School.  Additionally,  as as mentioned above, if the district had had a 20 year facility plan before the closures then Kimbell would have known the status of district buildings without having to ask the board at this time.

24.  March 31, 2005 - e-mail from citizen Jeanne Joscelyn to Superintendent Jim Clark regarding the March 29, 2005 Finance and Operations Meeting.  Joscelyn stated that she had not heard of Prescott School being termed an “excess building” in the many meetings that she had attended.  Nor had she observed this issue in writing and asked the Superintendent where this had been discussed.  The issue of excess school buildings had not come before the Finance and Operations Committee or the Board as a whole.  The Superintendent Clark never did respond to Joscelyn’s email!


Conclusion:  The legality of Naomi Kimbell’s actions in this public servant/private school issue has not been investigated; at the very least, just the appearance of wrongdoing by a board member(s) needs to be avoided so as to assure the public that the governance of their schools is in good hands, especially when it involves the valuable facilities of the district. 

Could the school closure decision in 2004 have been tilted toward closure based on future employment given to a trustee with a private entity involved in the closure/lease issue?   Since this issue, and other factors, such as the lack of a long term facilities plan and a professional demographic study, has not been resolved, there is a need for a moratorium on any future land lease or sale transactions in regard to Prescott School.

(reminder: this document was written in 2009 during lease extension discussions)








#4 - Naomi Kimbell: From Missoula County Public Schools Trustee to Executive Director of Missoula International School


                                           Part 4                  

16.  July 20, 2004 - Missoulian article written by Daryl Gadbow about the lease of Prescott School to the Missoula International School titled, “Private school leases Prescott. Missoula International plans to add fourth and fifth grades.”  The article was written one and one-half months after the lease was signed on June 9, 2004. 

Note #1:  Missoula International School was able to immediately expand to two more grade levels as a result of leasing Prescott School.  The increase in MIS enrollment is of significant importance to MCPS as these students are from the same school boundaries as MCPS - in other words - for every student that does not attend MCPS and attends MIS the school district loses thousands of dollars - approximately $4,000 to $5,000 per student.  As pointed out by a nearby resident of Prescott School, just the school itself is a selling point for MIS. 

17.  August 3, 2004 - Missoulian article written by Betsy Cohen titled, “MCPS trustee resigns; Kimbell says new job could cause conflict of interest.”  The article discusses Kimbell accepting a new job as executive director of Missoula International School and that Kimbell thought it was best to resign from the MCPS school board for conflict of interest reasons.  Key quotes from the article state, “While on the board Kimbell was part of the decision- making process to close Prescott and also to rent it to the Missoula International School.” and “Her resignation takes effect August 12th, two days after the board finalizes the 2004-2005 budget at its August 10th Meeting.”  Kimbell is also quoted as saying, “Given that Missoula International School is an independent school, sometimes their interests are different from public schools.  If I’m going to be a leader in public schools and in my new job, at some point both roles would come into conflict.  My interest is in being fair to both.”

Note # 1: This is the first article that broke the news about an astounding aspect of the Prescott School/Missoula International School lease.  Prior to this article, the general public was unaware about a relationship between Naomi Kimbell and Missoula International School. Only by going back to view Kimbell's comments throughout the process, one can see that Kimbell supported MIS all along in addition to her voting to close Prescott (twice) and to vote for the lease to Missoula International School.

Note # 2: Kimbell's statements are secondary to the real issue at hand. There is no statement in the article about the possibility or even the need for an investigation into a possible job for a vote scenario.
18.  August 10, 2004 - monthly MCPS School Board Meeting - Board accepts resignation of K-12 Trustee Naomi Kimbell and Declare Her Position on the Board Vacant - Kimbell receives glowing reports and thank yous from many board members who joined her in voting for the school closures and for the Prescott School-Missoula International School lease.  Kimbell also received flowers from the board and a hug from Superintendent Jim Clark.  Quotes from the minutes from pro-closure trustees include:  From Trustee Jenda Hemphill, “Your integrity and honesty and no doubt that you were putting the children first (wording of minutes). Most open-minded board member on this board.  You helped us in some rough places.”  And from Board Chairwoman, Rosemary Harrison,
“An ethical, wonderful person.”  

19.  September 8, 2004 - Missoulian article by Betsy Cohen titled “MCPS board to select replacement trustee”.  The article states, “Trustees will meet to discuss and review the five candidates who wish to fill out the term of Naomi Kimbell, who resigned in August, citing potential conflicts between her new job as director of a Missoula private school and her trustee position.”   The article lists the 5 citizens; Thomas Orr, Eric Waeckerlin, Marlene Hutchins, Loren Meyer, and Heidi Davis.

20.  September 9, 2004 - MCPS Special Board Meeting - Thomas Orr was voted by the board to fill the vacant seat left by Kimbell’s resignation. The board packet included a variety of letters from the applicants, a resume, responses from the applicants to a series of questions adopted by the board, and five letters of endorsement for applicant Marlene Hutchins.

21.  September 10, 2004 - Missoulian article by Vince Devlin – “Attorney appointed despite opposition to pop contract.”  The article states, “Orr – who called the sweetener used in soda pop “a poison” – was chosen from 5 applicants to fill out the term of Naomi Kimbell.  Kimbell resigned in August after being named director of a private school in Missoula.”  The article also states, “Trustee Scott Bixler delivered a ringing endorsement for Waeckerlin, his nephew by marriage, then recused himself from voting.”  Thomas Orr was sworn in at the September 2004 Board meeting.










Friday, July 13, 2012

#3 - Naomi Kimbell: From Missoula County Public Schools Trustee to Executive Director of Missoula International School


Naomi Kimbell:  From Missoula County Public Schools Trustee to Executive Director of Missoula International School

                                                                     Part 3

12.  June 8, 2004 – Letter to the Editor in the Missoulian by Rattlesnake resident/math professor David Patterson – Patterson’s letter explains that a lease of Prescott School had the potential to be financially devastating to the district.  His main reasoning was based on two premises: the low lease rate of the school to Missoula International School (The lease rate was $20,000 for the first 3 years and $30,000 for the last two years, which averages out over 5 years to be $1.19/per square foot!) and the enrollment-based funds that would be diverted from the public school system when students enroll in MIS. Patterson stated that if even 5 students enrolled in Missoula International School, due to its location, the school district would not receive any revenue from the lease, and could potentially lose tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands of dollars in future years of the lease.  An additional quote from the letter reads:  “Alternative uses of Prescott that do not compete with the public schools should be explored first.  Any agreement to rent to a private school should be at a rate that provides clear benefit to the school district.”

*Note #1:  David Patterson’s letter details very succinctly the financial pitfalls of leasing a public school to a private school.  As the board failed to set aside a separate meeting to discuss the lease, as suggested by a minority member, the trustees, which included Trustee Kimbell (and the public), were denied the opportunity to deliberate these very important ideas, thus not fulfilling its fiduciary duties. 
*Note # 2:  Missoula International School has doubled in size since leasing Prescott School leaving no doubt that the district is losing the tens of thousands of dollars and could possibly stand to lose hundreds of thousands of dollars over the life of the 5 year lease.

13.  June 8, 2004 - monthly MCPS School Board Meeting - Agenda Item: Discussion and Ratification of Contract between MCPS and Missoula International School for the Lease of Prescott Elementary School - The motion was moved by Jenda Hemphill and seconded by Trustee Naomi Kimbell.  There were 5 affirmative votes for the ratification of the lease, including Kimbell’s, and 2 abstentions because of conflict of interest issues.  Trustee Carol Bellin first excuses herself from the vote as her son had once attended Missoula International School.  Subsequently, new Trustee, Toni Rehbein, excused herself from the vote as she said she was once on the board of Missoula International School.


*Note#1: Public records reveal that Trustee Rehbein was President in 1999 and 2000 of Missoula International School!
*Note #2: Trustees voted on the lease of Prescott School to Missoula International School at the June 8, Board Meeting even though on the agenda to be discussed later in the evening was the litigation of the school closure decision.  The results of this litigation could potentially have reopened Prescott School!

14.  June 9, 2004 - Lease between MCPS for the lease of Prescott School to Missoula International School was signed by Chairwoman of the Board of Trustees of MCPS, Rosemary Harrison, Executive Director of Business Services, Bruce Moyer, and Board President of Missoula International School, Marta Pierpoint (The lease was ready to sign the day after the board meeting).  A phrase in the lease states, “The term of the lease shall be from August 1, 2004 through July 31, 2009.”  The term of the lease is for five years.
*Note:  MCPS was still in litigation in an Open Meeting Law lawsuit concerning the school closures when it went forward with the ratification of the lease of one of the schools involved in the closures!  A citizen knowledgeable about land issues has suggested that the attorney for the plaintiffs needed to issue a TRO  (this could be the wrong acronym) due to the district going forward with leasing Prescott School. The attorney did not attempt to issue a TRO
15.  July 13, 2004 - MCPS School Board Meeting - Agenda item:  Revisit 2004-2005 Preliminary Secondary Budget Decision of March 24, 2004                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               The  The school closure decision was again brought up before the school board due to a lawsuit addressing breaches of Montana Open Meeting Laws.  The board, with a new make-up because of spring elections as described above voted again to close the three schools with Trustee Kimbell voting with the majority, standing by her March 24, 2004 decision.  Motion passed 6-1 with Trustee Bellin opposed.








                

#2 - Naomi Kimbell: From Missoula County Public Schools Trustee to Executive Director of Missoula International School


Part Two

6.  April 27, 2004 - MCPS Finance and Operation Meeting - Agenda item - Request by the Missoula International School to lease Prescott Elementary School. - Background Information (listed with agenda):  Missoula International School has submitted a letter indicating an interest in renting all or part of Prescott School for the 2004-2005 school year.  Attached is a copy of the letter for discussion.  Administration recommendation:  None at this time. Also in question was whether MCPS needed to issue a formal RFP (Request for Proposal).  An RFP was deemed prudent by Bruce Moyer, the Business Director, and he recommended a 2-3 month time span.  While discussing the potential lease of Prescott School to Missoula International School, Trustee Kimbell’s comment and question were:  “Ms. Kimbell would like to move forward with leasing Prescott School to the Missoula International School.  She asked if they would maintain the building and grounds.”  It was stated that Missoula Catholic Schools maintains the buildings and grounds, including custodial, at the Roosevelt facility.

*Note:  There is a discrepancy between the MIS letter and district records as to the length of time requested for a lease.  As listed above in #4 the Missoula International School sent a letter on April 21st to the MCPS offices expressing interest in leasing Prescott School for a minimum of two years.  The district records as stated above state that the private school requested a lease for the 2004-2005 school year.  This discrepancy would have not been noticed by citizens that did not receive a packet for the meeting.  In fact, a citizen asking the district for a copy of the MIS letter a few years later and was surprised at this discrepancy as she had printed a flyer with erroneous information because of it.  This discrepancy was perhaps unintentional; however it conveys that the private school wanted a longer term lease than described in district records.  

7.  May 4, 2004 - Missoula County Public Schools School Board Election – There was three open seats on the ballot.  Two incumbent trustees who voted against the closures, Trustees Suzette Dussault and Colleen Rogers, ran but were not re-elected. Another incumbent trustee, David Merrill, who voted for the closures, chose not to run for re-election.  Marlene Hutchins also ran unsuccessfully for a position.  Three citizens who ran as a team were newly elected to the board: Toni Rehbein, Joe Toth, and Scott Bixler.  *Note:  Trustee Merrill ignored a mandate of keeping neighborhood schools open established when first elected, as he was elected to re-open Prescott School in 2001!



8.  May 11, 2004 - Missoulian article by Jane Rider – “Trustees to discuss renting to Missoula International School at meeting tonight.”

9.  May 11, 2004 – monthly MCPS School Board Meeting – Reorganization of Board of Trustees – Sentences from the minutes state:  “Trustee Bellin nominated Trustee Kimbell for the Chair position based on her experience in the process of involving the public.  Kimbell declined the nomination to be chair of the Board.  She thanked Bellin for the vote of confidence. Bellin concerned about having Harrison as chair again given litigation pending and processes involving public. Said she is concerned about propriety of chair actions in regard to e-mail sent to school full of teachers with false information about Bellin’s positions about issues on which she was voting.  Bellin asked Harrison to abstain from the position.  Harrison was elected chair of the Board for the next year.”

10.  May 11, 2004 - monthly MCPS School Board Meeting - Agenda Item:  Request of Missoula International School to Lease Prescott Elementary School – The school board discussed renting Prescott School to Missoula International School.  Trustee Bellin urged the trustees to allow 6 weeks for the RFP process.  Bellin moved to offer RFP’s with return date of three weeks time and two weeks time for consideration by the Board and public input, Kimbell seconded the motion. Quotes by Trustee Kimbell from the minutes state:  “Kimbell said would be July meeting when Board would be making a decision and that would truly be too long to expect MIS to wait.  Maybe school district could do different advertising of RFP and move quickly.” and Kimbell asked if a motion should include a special meeting date of Tuesday, June 15, 2004. and “Kimbell said do not believe making decision two days after the June 8 meeting is much different from making a decision at the June 8 meeting.  Kimbell in favor of making decision by June 8.  Believe it would become obvious very quickly if there will be any dissention about leasing to MIS.” and “Kimbell said Moyer brought up good point of difference between market values and value for having a school in our building.  Want to do whatever makes sense for our District.  If there were other interested parties, probably would have heard from them by now.”  The minutes also state:  “Bruce Moyer, Director of Business Services recommended that the Board and administration offer RFP’s to educational institutions only with a time line so that response and analysis may be presented at June 8 meeting.”

*Note #1: The RFP process was changed from Moyer’s earlier recommendation at the April meeting of 2-3 months.  Minutes of this meeting reveal statements made to support a time period of 1 to 2 months but finally whittled down to only 2 weeks!  Motion passed unanimously.

*Note #2:  The above quotes illustrate that Trustee Naomi Kimbell thought it was best to rush the lease process and lease Prescott School at a low rate to an educational institution rather than obtaining market value.
*Note #3:  The Finance and Operations Committee meeting was to be held on May 25, 2004, however, in a rush to bring the issue to the June 8 board meeting, the F&O meeting was changed to June 1, 2004.

11.  June 1, 2004 – Finance and Operation Committee Meeting – Agenda item:  Results of Request for Proposal (RFP) for Prescott School - There were no comments by Naomi Kimbell mentioned in the minutes.  The minutes read, “The F&O Committee recommends that the contract lease for Prescott School be ready for presentation to the Trustees for discussion and ratification at the June 8 Board meeting.”  A recommendation by Trustee Carol Bellin to include in the lease that the District had the option to cancel the lease if other District programs have the need for use of this building was ignored by Kimbell and other trustees.

*Note: While discussing All-Day Kindergarten during a November 2006 Property Ad Hoc meeting, Superintendent Clark stated that Prescott School was tied to a lease and would not be available for this program! 







Wednesday, May 30, 2012

August 3, 2004 Missoulian article "MCPS Trustee Naomi Kimbell resigns, becomes executive director of Missoula International School"

MCPS trustee resigns : Missoulian: News and Resources for Western Montana#comments

The above link is to a Missoulian article reporting on the resignation of Missoula County Public Schools Trustee Naomi Kimbell in 2004.  Trustee Kimbell resigned as she accepted a position of executive director with the Missoula International School shortly after three school closures.

The article states, "Given that Missoula International School is an independent school, sometimes their interests are different from public schools." Kimbell said. "If I'm going to be a leader in public schools and in my new job, at some point both roles would come into conflict."

AND - MOST IMPORTANTLY THE ARTICLE STATES, "WHILE ON THE BOARD, KIMBELL WAS PART OF THE DECISION-MAKING PROCESS TO CLOSE PRESCOTT AND ALSO TO RENT IT TO THE MISSOULA INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL."

Two Missoula County Public Schools Trustees, Naomi Kimbell and current Board Chairwoman Toni Rehbein have very strong ties to Missoula International School. Due to these ties and for other reasons, prescottschoolmissoula calls  the Prescott School/MIS (Missoula International School) lease "one of Missoula's biggest scandals involving one of Missoula's smallest schools".

Saturday, May 12, 2012

Three schools closed on April 25, 2004 - Missoulian article

Let's start at the very beginning...the day three of Missoula's popular neighborhood schools were closed. At 1:00 a.m. on the morning of April 25, 2004, after seven hours of heated deliberation, Missoula County Public Schools voted 4 to 3 to close three public schools in the north east corner of our city, Prescott School and Rattlesnake Middle School in the Rattlesnake Valley and Mount Jumbo School in East Missoula.  Below is the Missoulian article regarding the meeting.  The following day reverberations from this tragic decision could be felt throughout Missoula. The closure process by MCPS trustees and administrators took place only 48 days prior to the decision and had only begun wreaking havoc in Missoula's school system.
__________________________________________________________________________________

Jumbo, Prescott schools closed

JANE RIDER of the Missoulianmissoulian.com | Posted: Friday, March 26, 2004 12:00 am | Loading…

Amber Winkler, a student teacher at Mount Jumbo Elementary School, goes over multiplication problems with her third-grade class on Thursday. Early Thursday morning, the Missoula County Public Schools Board of Trustees voted to close Prescott and Mount Jumbo elementary schools.
Photo by JOSH PARKER/Missoulian


The Missoula County Public Schools Board of Trustees voted early Thursday morning to close Prescott and Mount Jumbo elementary schools and to turn Rattlesnake Middle School into a 360-student elementary school.

Trustees also instructed school administrators to retain the district's fifth-grade band and orchestra, its two elementary school art teachers and its one gifted-and-talented teacher.

The move means the district has closed all but $110,000 of a projected $860,000 shortfall in the elementary budget. Trustees instructed the board to cut the remainder from the district's discretionary funds.

The district's next step is to begin plans to relocate 345 students to MCPS's other middle schools by the fall of 2004-05. Principals have already begun meeting with small groups to begin that conversation, said MCPS Superintendent Jim Clark.

"I want to expand that," he said. "I want to include parents, kids, teachers and principals."

Four potential options for disbursement (see related story, A2) were provided to parents earlier this month, but Clark said the district will entertain other options as it gathers public input at community meetings.

Either the school board or administration will ultimately decide how to configure the district's middle school population. Clark said he will recommend the board direct administration to make that final decision. He expects community meetings to begin after spring break.

The board's 4-3 vote at about 1:30 a.m. Thursday, came after more than seven hours of discussion over the district's secondary and elementary budgets. Trustees Rosemary Harrison, Jenda Hemphill, David Merrill and Naomi DeMarinis voted in favor of the school closures and consolidation of Rattlesnake. Trustees Suzette Dussault, Carol Bellin and Colleen Rogers voted against.

The vote came after an earlier motion to close Prescott School and ship its students to Mount Jumbo failed, also on a 4-3 vote. Bellin, Rogers and Merrill voted for that motion; Dussault, DeMarinis, Harrison and Hemphill voted against.

Trustees then bogged down in nearly two hours of what DeMarinis called "stream-of-consciousness budgeting," in which they attempted to find various places to trim to produce a balanced budget.

During the evening, Prescott Principal Cindy Christensen made an emotional plea to the board to move ahead with closing Prescott, where enrollment has declined to just 128 students, expressing how emotionally and educationally difficult the threat of closure has been on the school's staff and students in recent years.

"This is not what's best for kids," Christensen said. She also argued that the school population has shrunk to a size of diminished energy.

Finally, Larry Johnson, the district's assistant superintendent for personnel and special services, asked trustees if they would support a package of some of the proposals offered by the administration. Specifically, Johnson asked if the board could accept a package that closed Prescott School, moved those students to Mount Jumbo, but kept Rattlesnake as a middle school.

Hemphill asked whether the board could restore the art, music and gifted-education programs - all of which were on the chopping block - if it moved ahead with the original recommendation to close both Prescott and Mount Jumbo and reconfigure Rattlesnake as a K-5 school. That, finally, was the essence of the motion that passed the board.

Merrill had indicated earlier in a straw vote that he wouldn't support closing Rattlesnake Middle School, but after the lengthy and futile effort to find money elsewhere to close the budget gap, he stated he was willing to close the middle school.

I'm not comfortable putting this off," he said. "This has been a very difficult process. I don't think we should continue down this path of indecision. I'm willing to change my vote."

Johnson noted earlier in the evening that if the board waited past the March 24 deadline to make a budget decision, it would reduce his ability to recruit the best and brightest teachers at area job fairs.

"I think the outcome is the best we can do, given the resources we have," Clark said later Thursday, while visiting Rattlesnake Middle School to answer questions from staff and students.

"After all the discussion and all of the agonizing over this, the majority of the board came to the realization that there just weren't other viable options to look at. That's a discouraging thing, but that is just a reflection of 10 years of cutting into that budget," he said.

The elementary budget also includes the expectation that Missoula residents will pass a $142,193 operating levy, which will be placed on the May 4 election ballot. If the levy passes, the owner of a home with a market value of $150,000 would pay about $5.70 more in school property taxes.

The preliminary elementary budget approved Thursday left out the closure of Lowell Elementary School, the privatization of printing or courier services, and the elimination of any central library positions. The board initially considered these items for reduction early in the budget process, but removed them after public input and board discussion.

Also during the late-night budget session, the 11-member board approved a tentative high school budget that included a $150,000 beverage contract and about $300,000 from a building reserve levy that would offset costs currently paid for from the general fund. The actual amount of the building reserve levy that voters will be asked to approve will be $450,000 annually for seven years. Passage of that levy will increase the property taxes on a home with a market value of $150,000 by about $10.92.

The board did vote to eliminate seven high school teaching positions, which schools are expected to absorb mostly through retirements. Clark said Thursday that building principals and academic department heads will meet to decide how best to disburse those cuts across the district's four high schools.

Originally, the administration had proposed eliminating golf, tennis and swimming and some sophomore sports, but those cuts came off the table after public and trustee input, and after the district learned it would receive additional special education revenues that reduced the need for those cuts.

Public comments after the two budget decisions early Thursday morning did reveal deep division remains on the board.

"The decision tonight is enormously harmful to our kids," Dussault said. "It's not in the long-term interest of the district."

Added Rogers: "I don't think we know the ramifications of the decision. Å  We'll be right back here next year, making cuts."

Harrison provided the counterpoint: "I really do feel that we have made a good decision, and that makes me feel glad," she said.

Some trustees and members of the public who stayed until the end of the meeting called for greater public involvement in the budgeting process. They noted that the budget team that crafted the recommendations presented to the board included district officials and principals, but no members of the board or the public. Bellin said she hoped that next year the district would not have "an exclusive administration-only budget team."

For his part, Clark told the board, "I want you to know how much I've struggled with this. And I don't think you know that." He called it "the most difficult budget issue I've ever had."

Reporter Jane Rider can be reached at 523-5298 or at jrider@missoulian.com

Copyright 2012 missoulian.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.



School daze | Features | Missoula Independent

Click on the link below to read an article on the 2004 Missoula School closures writted by Keila Szpalier of the Missoula Independent (now with the Missoulian).

School daze Features Missoula Independent


Keila Szpalier did such an excellent job in her article reporting on the proposed school closures in 2004. As this article is quite long, I've decided to post just some of  the many interesting quotes and information.


"On March 24, school board trustees will vote on how to balance the budget. Five years ago, the administration asked the board—with three of the same elementary trustees—to solve similar budget problems by closing Emma Dickinson and Roosevelt elementary schools, and once again, the administration is recommending school closures to manage deficits."

and -

"Lowell, Prescott and Mount Jumbo are on the chopping block not because closures are part of a long-range plan, not because the proposed closures have been subjected to careful scrutiny and found beneficial, not because the administration believes busing children to larger central schools results in higher quality education, not even because the school district expects to realize long-term financial gain from school closures. It doesn’t. In Missoula, schools close in response to red ink."

and -

"In 1999, the administration gave board trustees just two weeks to review the option of closing Emma Dickinson."

and - 
"Lowell, Prescott and Mount Jumbo are on the chopping block not because closures are part of a long-range plan, not because the proposed closures have been subjected to careful scrutiny and found beneficial, not because the administration believes busing children to larger central schools results in higher quality education, not even because the school district expects to realize long-term financial gain from school closures. It doesn’t. In Missoula, schools close in response to red ink."

and -

"Keith Fank, who has two children at Chief Charlo, fails to understand how Missoula has a brand new jail but can’t support its schools. He wouldn’t like to see his children bused across town, and he does not support the closure of schools in other neighborhoods: “Kids should get to go to school with kids in their neighborhood and kind of grow up with them instead of getting shuffled because somebody can’t handle the books.”"
and -
 
"Not Missoula. One administration proposal is that children from Lowell, Prescott and Mount Jumbo be bused up to Rattlesnake Middle School. Children currently at Rattlesnake Middle School would be bused elsewhere. There is no clear plan for their distribution."
 
and -
 "What this school district has become good at,” says former Emma Dickinson parent Bill Comstock, “is how to move small human bodies around efficiently.”

and -

 
"The school district simply raises taxes to accommodate transportation to and from school, because it can. The social and environmental costs of busing aren’t a priority for the administration."

Edited on December 17th, 2013